30 Stars Who Look Nothing Like Their Characters

This post may contain affiliate links. Read our disclosure page for more info.

We've all seen it before. An actor who looks nothing like their character on the big screen. We've all seen it before. It can be pretty jarring and often leaves us wondering how they even got the part in the first place. In this article, we will look at 30 actors who don't look anything like their characters! Some of them are so different that you might not even recognize them!

1. Scathach vs. Lady Gaga

Photo Credit: AdMedia

We all know Lady Gaga for her outlandish fashion sense and outrageous persona. But did you know that she started her career as a relatively average-looking person?

That's right before she was the world-famous Lady Gaga, she was just Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta. She even played a relatively normal character on the hit show American Horror Story: Hotel.

But when she was cast as Scathach in American Horror Story: Roanoke, she underwent a complete transformation.

The character's wild, feral look is far from Gaga's usual out-there fashion.

2. Rebecca Pearson vs. Mandy Moore

Photo credit: Carrie-nelson

Mandy Moore is best known for her roles in romantic comedies and teen dramas. She's always been the girl-next-door type with a down-to-earth personality.

But when she was cast as Rebecca Pearson in This Is Us, she took on the role of a woman who has been through some tough times.

The character is hardened by her experiences, which is reflected in her appearance. Moore looks completely different than she does in her other roles, having been seemingly aged several years.

3. Dwight vs. Austin Amelio

Photo by Xavier Collin/Image Press Agency

Austin Amelio is best known for his role as Dwight on The Walking Dead. He's a rough and tumble sort of guy who has been through many challenging situations.

But in real life, Amelio looks nothing like his character. He's pretty clean-cut and well-groomed.

It's amazing what a little (or a lot) of makeup can do to change someone's appearance!

4. Mrs. Hughes vs. Phyllis Logan

Courtesy of Keith Mayhew/Landmark Media

Phyllis Logan is best known for her role as Mrs. Hughes on Downton Abbey. She's a no-nonsense woman who keeps a tight rein on the household staff.

Ready to make your first budget?

Enter your email and get the free template


But in real life, Logan looks nothing like her character. She's pretty glamorous and stylish.

It just shows that you can't always judge a book by its cover!

5. Emmit Stussy vs. Ewan McGregor

Courtesy of Byron Purvis/AdMedia

Ewan McGregor is best known for his roles in the Star Wars prequels and the Harry Potter movies. He's a versatile actor who can play both good and bad guys.

But when he was cast as Emmit Stussy in Fargo, he took on the role of an ordinary man who gets caught up in a criminal scheme.

The character is downtrodden and unassuming, reflected in McGregor's appearance. He looks completely different than he does in his other roles!

How I make $11,000 per year renting out my spare rooms?

Get access to my FREE guide now.


6. Pepper vs. Naomi Grossman

Courtesy of FSadou/AdMedia

Naomi Grossman is best known for her role as Pepper in American Horror Story: Freak Show. Her character is a small woman who suffers from microcephaly.

But in real life, Grossman looks nothing like her character. She does not suffer from this condition. She spent hours in the makeup chair to achieve this impressive transformation.

7. Rust Cohle vs. Matthew McConaughey

Courtesy of Acepixs

Matthew McConaughey is best known for his roles in romantic comedies and dramas. But when he was cast as Rust Cohle in True Detective, he took on the role of a dark and brooding character.

The character is haunted by his past, which is reflected in McConaughey's appearance. He looks tired and world-weary, which is far from his usual charming self.

8. Daenerys Targaryen vs. Emilia Clarke

Courtesy of Birdie Thompson/AdMedia

Emilia Clarke is best known for her role as Daenerys Targaryen in Game of Thrones. Her character is a strong and powerful woman who has been through many challenging situations.

But in real life, Clarke looks nothing like her character. She's pretty petite and delicate-featured.

9. Tiffany \”Pennsatucky\” Doggett vs. Taryn Manning

Courtesy of Retna/AdMediaCourt

Taryn Manning is best known for her role as Tiffany “Pennsatucky” Doggett in Orange Is the New Black. Her character is a white supremacist who is serving time in prison.

But in real life, Manning looks nothing like her character. She's quite pretty and feminine.

10. The Hound vs. Rory McCann

Courtesy of Byron Purvis/AdMedia

Rory McCann is best known for his role as Sandor “The Hound” Clegane in Game of Thrones. His character is a brutal and violent man who has been through many challenging situations.

But in real life, McCann looks nothing like his character. He's pretty handsome and ruggedly good-looking.

11. Kitty Sanchez vs. Judy Greer

Courtesy of Birdie Thompson/AdMedia

Judy Greer is best known for her role as Kitty Sanchez in Arrested Development. Her character is a ditzy and incompetent assistant to the Bluth family.

But in real life, Greer looks nothing like her character. She's pretty intelligent and put together.

12. Walter White vs. Bryan Cranston

Courtesy of Birdie Thompson/AdMedia

Bryan Cranston is best known for his role as Walter White in Breaking Bad. His character has a bald head, facial hair, and signature glasses.

But in real life, Cranston looks nothing like his character. He's pretty handsome and has a full head of hair.

13. Betty Suarez vs. America Ferrera

Courtesy of Birdie Thompson/AdMedia

America Ferrera is best known for her role as Betty Suarez in Ugly Betty. Her character is an unattractive and awkward young woman who works at a fashion magazine.

But in real life, Ferrera looks nothing like her character. She's pretty beautiful and stylish.

14. Brienne of Tarth vs. Gwendoline Christie

Courtesy of Birdie Thompson/AdMedia

Gwendoline Christie is best known for her role as Brienne of Tarth in Game of Thrones. Her character is a tall and muscular woman who is a skilled warrior.

But in real life, Christie looks nothing like her character. She's pretty petite and delicate-featured.

15. Madea vs. Tyler Perry

Courtesy of Xavier Collin/Image Press Agency

Tyler Perry is best known for his role as Madea in the Tyler Perry movies. His character is a large, loud, and outspoken woman.

Tyler does not even remotely resemble this character. The makeup and acting were quite impressive, and he represented his character perfectly.

16. Alexanya Atoz vs. Kristen Wiig

Courtesy of F. Sadou/AdMedia

Kristen Wiig is best known for her role as Alexanya Atoz in Zoolander. Her character is a highly over-the-top villain. She revealed that she spent 5 hours in the makeup chair to achieve the iconic look.

But in real life, Wiig looks nothing like her character. She's pretty down-to-earth. Her lips are standard-sized, and her hairstyles are quite demure compared to her character.

17. Ichabod Crane vs. Tom Mison

Courtesy of Carrie-nelson

Tom Mison is best known for his role as Ichabod Crane in Sleepy Hollow. His character is a man out of time who was transported from the 18th century to the 21st century.

But in real life, Mison looks nothing like his character. He's quite handsome and dapper. His hair is modernly styled, and he doesn't have the same awkwardness as his character does.

18. Jerri Blank vs. Amy Sedaris

Courtesy of Adam Nemser-PHOTOlink.net

Amy Sedaris is best known for her role as Jerri Blank in Strangers with Candy. Her character is an overweight and unattractive middle-aged woman who is a former drug addict and prostitute.

But in real life, Sedaris looks nothing like her character. She's quite slim and attractive. She doesn't have the same rough edges that her character does.

19. Blanca Flores vs. Laura Gomez

Courtesy of Byron Purvis/AdMedia

Laura Gomez is best known for her role as Blanca Flores in Orange Is the New Black. Her character is a challenging and hardened woman who has been through a lot in her life.

But in real life, Gomez looks nothing like her character. She's quite soft-featured and beautiful.

20. Khal Drogo vs. Jason Momoa

Courtesy of Xavier Collin/Image Press Agency

Jason Momoa is best known for his role as Khal Drogo in Game of Thrones. His character is a large and muscular barbarian who is a skilled warrior.

While Jason retains the gruff countenance of the character, he is much more refined and much less feral.

21. Ofwarren vs. Madeline Brewer

Courtesy of Birdie Thompson/AdMedia

Madeline Brewer is best known for her role as Ofwarren in The Handmaid's Tale. Her character is a meek and submissive woman who has been forced into sexual servitude.

But in real life, Brewer looks nothing like her character. She doesn't have the same downtrodden look that her character does. She's actually quite strong and confident.

22. Eleven vs. Millie Bobby Brown

Courtesy of Peter West/ACE Pictures

Millie Bobby Brown is best known for her role as Eleven in Stranger Things. Her character is a young girl with supernatural powers.

But in real life, Brown looks nothing like her character. She's mature-looking for her age (and may not lack the superpowers).

23. Dwight Schrute vs. Rainn Wilson

Courtesy of Birdie Thompson/AdMedia

Rainn Wilson is best known for his role as Dwight Schrute in The Office. His character is an eccentric and obsessive man who always tries to prove himself.

But in real life, Wilson looks nothing like his character. He's quite normal and down to earth. He doesn't have the same quirks that his character does.

24. Stephen Bonnet vs. Ed Speleers

Courtesy of StillsPress

Ed Speleers is best known for his role as Stephen Bonnet in Outlander. His character is a ruthless pirate who has no regard for human life.

But in real life, Speleers looks nothing like his character. He's quite handsome and charming. He doesn't have the same hardened look that his character does.

25. Queen Victoria vs. Jenna Coleman

Courtesy of Keith Mayhew/Landmark Media

Jenna Coleman is best known for her role as Queen Victoria in Victoria. Her character is a strong and determined woman who ruled over the British Empire.

But in real life, Coleman looks nothing like her character. She doesn't have the same regal bearing that her character does. She's actually quite gentle and soft-spoken.

26. Roger McKenzie Wakefield vs. Richard Rankin

Courtesy of Carrie-nelson

Richard Rankin is best known for his role as Roger McKenzie Wakefield in Outlander. His character is a shy and introverted man who is a historian.

But in real life, Rankin looks nothing like his character. He's quite outgoing and charismatic. He has a much more refined look than his scruffy, long-haired character.

27. Ruth Langmore vs. Julia Garner

Courtesy of Image Press Agency

Julia Garner is best known for her role as Ruth Langmore in Ozark. Her character is a challenging and street-smart woman who is a criminal.

But in real life, Garner looks nothing like her character. She doesn't have the same hard edges that her character does. She's actually quite gentle and feminine.

28. Gianni Versace vs. Edgar Ramirez

Courtesy of Xavier Collin/Image Press Agency

Edgar Ramirez is best known for his role as Gianni Versace in The Assassination of Gianni Versace. His character is a striking and outrageous fashion designer.

But in real life, Ramirez looks nothing like his character. He doesn't have the same over-the-top look and greying hair as his character.

29. Leonard Hofstadter vs. Johnny Galecki

Courtesy of Xavier Collin/Image Press Agency

Johnny Galecki is best known for his role as Leonard Hofstadter in The Big Bang Theory. His character is a nerdy and awkward physicist.

But in real life, Galecki looks nothing like his character. icated. He doesn't have the same geeky demeanor that his charact He's actually quite handsome and suave.er does.

30. Peggy Olson vs. Elisabeth Moss

Courtesy of FS/AdMedia

Elisabeth Moss is best known for her role as Peggy Olson in Mad Men. Her character is a shy and timid woman who works in advertising.

But in real life, Moss looks nothing like her character. She's a far cry from the plain Jane secretary turned advertising superstar that is her character.

Final Thoughts

It's always interesting to see how different an actor can look from their on-screen persona. It's always interesting to see how different an actor can look from their on-screen persona. These are just a few examples of actors who look nothing like their characters. There are many more out there.

More articles from the wealth of geeks network:

This article was produced by Max My Money and syndicated by Wealth of Geeks.

Featured Image Credit: Birdie Thompson/AdMedia.

Website | + posts

Claire started Femme on FIRE after struggling with the debt cycle and realizing that she had to create better habits to get out of it. She became inspired along this journey and now strives to help others achieve financial freedom as well. When she isn’t working on her blog, you can find her on the couch with a good book, cooking up recipes in the kitchen, or playing outside with her ducks.